Friday, July 12, 2024

Rape, consent, energy (and femicide)

The sudden success of the French movie Le Consentement (“Consent”) by Vanessa Filho, which has reached an sudden viewers, has put the notion of consent again on the centre of public debate in France, but in addition elsewhere in Europe.

The movie is an adaptation of Vanessa Springora’s e book of the identical identify, revealed in 2020, which tells the story of the connection between the writer and the author Gabriel Matzneff (who’s now the topic of additional accusations of sexual assault on minors). Because the story unfolds, the writer is 14 years outdated and Matzneff is 50. Their relationship is on public show, for households, society, and public opinion.

The “revolution of consent”

The textual content takes a collective step in the direction of placing phrases to so many questions that permeate the historical past of masculinity and femininity, energy and violence, and exploded with #MeToo. What’s consent? What does it imply to consent to a relationship, to sexual activity? What’s the energy relationship that runs by intimate relationships? #MeToo was a ‘revolution of consent’, writes Mediapart.

Upon launch, Vanessa Filho’s movie was a discreet success with the general public, particularly among the many city, educated center class, explains Le Monde. Then one thing sudden occurred: ten days after its launch, “younger individuals, below twenty, ladies as younger as fifteen, in {couples}, with mates or dad and mom, many from working-class neighbourhoods, who didn’t know there was a e book” went to the cinema. This viewers accounts for virtually half of the recorded admissions. What occurred? TikTok turned the movie right into a ‘phenomenon’, an intimate occasion, says Radio France. These younger ladies filmed themselves getting into and leaving the theatres. Some in tears. The hashtag #leconsentement has reached 32 million views on the time of writing. The e book, which was promoting about 1,800 copies a month, had bought 17,500 copies by October.

Obtain one of the best of European journalism straight to your inbox each Thursday

One other movie on the identical theme tells the story of younger individuals’s relationship to intercourse, love and consent: Learn how to Have Intercourse, by Molly Manning Walker (which gained the Un Sure Regard prize at Cannes). In The Guardian, Barbara Ellen invitations everybody to go and see this movie as a result of it tells us “a elementary devastating fact: that, nevertheless a lot sexual consent is theorised, debated and culturally disinfected, ‘out within the subject’, the place it issues, the place the true ladies and boys are, it stays a slippery idea, and too typically a non-existent one.” In accordance with Allen, “It’s time to acknowledge that predators exploit the loopholes and small print of sexual consent. That, to them, reluctant acquiescence continues to be authorized assent. Additionally, to recognise that younger individuals could be clued-up, but nonetheless weak.”

Consent within the definition of rape

On 14 November, the European Parliament, the Fee and the member states met once more to debate the proposed directive on combating violence in opposition to ladies and home violence launched on 8 March 2022 to outline what constitutes sexual violence (rape, together with marital rape, mutilation, compelled marriage, compelled sterilisation, harassment…) and accredited in June 2023 by MEPs, as reported by the Franco-German TV channel Arte.

Final June, nevertheless, the justice ministers of some international locations – France particularly, but in addition Hungary, Poland, Croatia, the Czech Republic and Germany – opposed Article 5, which defines rape as “absence of consent”.  As Le Monde explains, these international locations base their opposition, no less than formally, on the truth that solely so-called “euro crimes” – corruption, terrorism and sexual exploitation – included in Article 83 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the EU (TfUe) are inside the remit of European legislation, whereas crimes equivalent to rape are addressed by nationwide felony codes.

After which there’s one other drawback, each cultural and social: easy methods to use, outline and take into consideration the notion of consent from a authorized standpoint. We all know, on the idea of research – Nature, Could 2023 for instance – and customary sense, that worry doesn’t at all times present itself in bodily resistance or perhaps a “no”, whether or not loud and clear or barely whispered. In the meantime, “sure” is available in completely different types and for various causes. Whereas the idea could also be current in customs and vocabularies, from a authorized perspective it’s a advanced problem.

Within the columns of Libération, the American feminist and jurist Catherine MacKinnon – to whom we owe the authorized battle for the definition of sexual harassment, and who has simply revealed Le Viol redéfini (“Rape Redefined”, Flammarion 2023) – opposes altering the legislation in France, which defines rape as a sexual act dedicated with “violence, coercion, risk or shock”.

“If you wish to change the legislation, make specific the gender inequalities that exist in firms, intimate relationships, {couples} and households. How are you going to train consent when you find yourself in a scenario of social inequality? Consent is used to justify the obedience of the powerless to the legislation of the highly effective,’ MacKinnon explains. In accordance with the jurist, the present legislation needs to be improved not with the idea of consent, however “by together with the dimension of inequality: class, age, ‘races’, minority standing, nationality, faith, incapacity, the listing is in depth and detailed within the legislation”.

On gender-based violence 

World wide, 45,000 ladies and ladies have been killed by a companion or relative in 2022, in accordance with estimates within the UN Ladies report Gender-Associated Killings of Ladies and Ladies (Femicide/Feminicide)

In Europe, roughly two ladies are killed each week by a companion or member of the family, in accordance with the European Fee. The information lacks precision as a result of imprecise definitions and heterogeneous knowledge assortment. The MIIR examine performed with the European Knowledge Journalism Community (EDJNet) that we revealed in 2022 stories that greater than 6,500 ladies (a conservative estimate) died within the EU by the hands of a companion or member of the family between 2011 and 2021.

On 1 October, the Istanbul Conference on stopping and combating violence in opposition to ladies and home violence entered into power within the EU, Eunews stories. This regardless of six international locations refusing to ratify it (Bulgaria, Czech Republic, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania and Slovakia). In accordance with the aforementioned TfUe they should comply as a result of the worldwide agreements concluded by the Union “bind the EU establishments and the member states”.

Graziella Balestrieri | L’Unità | 22 November | IT

Giulia Cecchettin was a 22-year-old pupil. On 11 November, she was killed by her ex, Filippo Turetta, with whom she had remained on pleasant phrases. Because the starting of the yr, in accordance with knowledge from the Italian Ministry of the Inside, 102 ladies have been killed. 82 of those ladies have been killed in a household and/or intimate context, and 53 have been killed by their companion (or former companion).

Journalist Ida Dominijanni, interviewed by L’Unità, provides a systemic studying of this phenomenon in opposition to discourses – unfold on speak exhibits, or by politicians – that scale back it to easy crime or particular person deviance. “There’s a complete part of opinion makers who’re shocked that there are fewer femicides in Italy than in northern European international locations, and draw the conclusion that it’s due to this fact improper to attribute femicide to a patriarchal tradition. Behind this objection lies a complete ignorance of what patriarchy is. Patriarchy is a cross-cultural socio-symbolic system, which is present in numerous types in several cultures, and isn’t defeated by democracy. We’re coping with a post-patriarchy, which is now not the standard patriarchy, by which ladies didn’t even have to be killed, as a result of they have been domesticated. Now we’ve a wounded patriarchy, wounded by ladies’s earned freedom, which then reacts to this freedom in a brutal method”.

In partnership with Show Europe, cofunded by the European Union. Views and opinions expressed are nevertheless these of the writer(s) solely and don’t essentially mirror these of the European Union or the Directorate‑Common for Communications Networks, Content material and Know-how. Neither the European Union nor the granting authority could be held answerable for them.

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles