Glavin: ‘Associates’ of Palestinians ought to deal with support, not intifada

Article content material

“The lack of any harmless life is a tragedy — Israeli or Palestinian. Hamas not solely takes Israelis hostage, but in addition holds Palestinians hostage. Hamas isn’t solely the enemy of Jews, however the enemy of Palestinians, of peace, of human rights, and an enemy of our widespread humanity.”

There isn’t any convincing case that may be made towards the target and ethical fact of these phrases. They have been spoken this week by Irwin Cotler, Canada’s former justice minister and the founding father of the Raoul Wallenberg Centre for Human Rights, in assist of the federal authorities’s simply introduced sanctions on the 11 Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad warlords who directed the Oct. 7 atrocities in Israel.

Article content material

Article content material

I ought to say right away that I’m a senior fellow with the Wallenberg Centre, I’m a hardline advocate of extreme world sanctions towards human rights abusers and I’ve confessed greater than as soon as that in issues of political morality and worldwide human rights, Irwin Cotler is my lodestar. So take what I write right here with as many grains of salt as you want.

In any case, I’m going to depart apart questions and arguments in regards to the effectiveness and utility of levelling Canadian sanctions towards the already terrorist-listed masterminds of the ghastly Oct. 7 pogrom that claimed the lives of almost 1,200 individuals in Israel. I’ll solely be aware in passing that there are one other 33 Palestinian terror chieftains who may have appeared on International Affairs’ sanctions checklist, however didn’t. And for causes nobody has been capable of clarify, the fountainhead of all this terror, the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps in Tehran, remains to be not registered on Canada’s terrorist checklist.

Cotler is appropriate that the lack of any harmless life is a tragedy, and the warfare triggered by the carnage of Oct. 7 has up to now price the lives of maybe 20,000 Palestinian non-combatants in Gaza. Due to that, I’m turning right here to Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib, a Palestinian refugee, a patriot, and a brave Center East analyst whose perspective could be understood as an Arab iteration of Cotler’s standpoint.

Article content material

I nonetheless can’t discover any event of Alkhatib’s interventions in debates in regards to the Israel-Palestinian conundrum through which he’s turned out to be fallacious. So it’s helpful to concentrate to what Alkhatib says. And he says this:

Now greater than ever, there needs to be a worldwide motion to power Israeli authorities, the United Nations’ numerous businesses and western governments to deal with relieving the struggling of the Palestinians of Gaza. However right here’s what’s standing in the best way: Palestinians’ western “mates” are Palestinians’ worst enemies. They’ve sucked the life out of each dialog the place measures to carry the load of agony from the Palestinians of Gaza needs to be the one merchandise on the agenda.

For years, Alkhatib has tried to develop humanitarian lifelines into Gaza, to seek out methods across the troubled UN Reduction and Works Company (UNRWA), to construct assist for a UN-supervised worldwide airport past the management of Hamas, and so forth. However as Gaza’s struggling has develop into extra acute than at any level in its historical past, the prospects for real assist for the individuals of Gaza has by no means been so distant.

Article content material

“And so I’ve been attempting to place my voice on the market, out of sheer frustration and anger with these people who find themselves talking on behalf of the Palestinian individuals. These are the people who find themselves speculated to be highlighting the plight of the Palestinians. They’re speculated to be humanizing the struggling of the individuals of Gaza, and attempting to impact public opinion in western audiences, to maneuver issues ahead.

“As an alternative you get this ineffective feel-good activism. I’ve tried to be measured, and it’s proving to be very, very difficult. I’ve tried. I need to say this extra forcefully. I’ve tried to be measured, however numerous the so-called ‘pro-Palestine’ motion is now overtly pro-terror, and pro-Hamas, and professional Islamism.”

A minimum of 30 members of Alkhatib’s household in Gaza have been killed because the warfare started, so I wished to know the way his remaining kin are getting on.

As of final weekend, an aunt he’d misplaced contact with was on the Al Amal Hospital along with her daughters and grandchildren in Khan Younis, in order that was a reduction to study. Round 8,000 displaced Gazans had been sheltering on the hospital for a number of weeks, and the Israel Protection Forces are disputing studies that troopers “stormed” the hospital this week to evacuate it, so for now there’s nothing to do however wait to listen to what’s occurring there.

Article content material

On Oct. 13, Alkhatib’s childhood residence in Gaza Metropolis was destroyed in an Israeli airstrike. Among the many many members of the family sheltering there, all survived with accidents, a few of them life-threatening — all aside from his 13-year-old cousin Farah, who was killed immediately.

Alkhatib’s mom is within the United Arab Emirates after having obtained a visa to go to a daughter there instantly earlier than the warfare started, so no less than she’s protected. On Dec. 14, an Israeli airstrike destroyed her personal childhood residence in Rafah, the Gaza Strip’s southernmost metropolis. Among the many 31 individuals who died in the home that day — 9 kids amongst them — have been 5 of Alkhatib’s aunts and uncles, and most of his cousins.

His uncle Riyad was killed in one other airstrike in Gaza Metropolis, and his uncle Rahim is caught there attempting to look after a bodily disabled son who can’t simply be moved. The remainder of the household is dispersed all through the Gaza Strip. Alkhatib’s father, a health care provider, handed away three years in the past, so no less than he didn’t reside to see what has develop into of his beloved Gaza.

Alkhatib left to review in america in 2005. Two years later, Hamas seized Gaza from the Palestinian Authority, and Alkhatib was granted asylum in america the place he earned a level in intelligence research from American Army College and now works primarily within the area of worldwide support, largely privately funded initiatives in Africa. He nonetheless can’t perceive why his proposal for World Meals Programme airdrops into Gaza, to forestall a looming famine, hasn’t gotten any traction.

Article content material

Alkhatib has no variety phrases for the Israelis’ prosecution of the warfare: regardless of the efforts the IDF is making to maintain non-combatants out of hurt’s manner, tens of 1000’s of Gazan civilians have been killed and wounded. Roughly half the buildings within the Gaza Strip have been destroyed, no less than half the inhabitants of about two million individuals resides in rubble or in tents and below tarpaulins, and persons are sick and hungry and terrified. The scent of dying is in all places.

That’s what the “pro-Palestine” motion needs to be targeted on, Alkhatib says. “As an alternative, they’re operating round chanting ‘from the river to the ocean.’ These individuals wouldn’t final a second dwelling below Hamas in Gaza. However all we hear from them is ‘resistance’ and ‘intifada.’ These phrases imply nothing to Palestinians aside from warfare and dying.”

Irwin Cotler is correct, and Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib is correct: The lack of any harmless life is a tragedy. And innocents in Gaza proceed to die.

Terry Glavin is an writer and journalist.

Article content material